Change Cycles: Can Churches and Leaders Grow Together?
November 7, 2024
Trapped in the Moment Before the Miracle
November 14, 2024
Leadership When There Are No Solutions
Adaptive Change
By Pastor Vinnie MacIsaac
To listen to this article click here
Have you ever faced a problem that felt too big to solve? What do we do when we hit a wall and no amount of effort or expertise seems to fix it? How do we lead others through challenges we can’t fully grasp ourselves? When there’s no guidebook or blueprint for success–where do we turn?
Imagine you’re leading a church community, and for years, young adults have been drifting away. You’ve tried everything–new programs, social events, even hiring a youth pastor–but attendance keeps dropping. You’ve reached out to other churches, done the research, and tried all the usual strategies, but nothing addresses the core issue. Deep down, you wonder if this isn’t just about attendance. Maybe it’s about something deeper–a disconnect between the church’s message and what young people are seeking today.
So, what do you do when there’s no easy fix? This is where adaptive change and adaptive leadership come into play. Adaptive change isn’t about applying quick fixes or “technical solutions.” Instead, it invites us to slow down and ask new, sometimes uncomfortable questions: How can the church truly connect with young adults today? What are they seeking in a faith community? Adaptive change means rethinking church culture, opening space for genuine, honest conversations, and reimagining approaches. It requires new perspectives, humility, and, most of all, a willingness to grow–even when it’s hard.
By leaning into adaptive change, churches can experiment with fresh approaches, listen deeply, and build a community that resonates with people in ways traditional methods might miss.
You know it’s time for adaptive change when your technical fixes don’t work. In other words, if hiring an expert, reading a book, or following a YouTube video could solve the problem, you would do it. But when no known solutions exist, even among experts, it’s time to engage in the process of adaptive leadership. Adaptive change is created by building adaptive capacity and enhancing relationships.
What Is Adaptive Change, and Why Does It Matter?
Adaptive change is a strategic approach for leaders and organizations facing complex problems that can’t be solved with existing tools or knowledge. It’s about walking a path of discovery together, asking tough questions, and allowing space for growth–even when it challenges us.
The concept of adaptive change was developed by Ronald Heifetz and Marty Linsky at Harvard University. In their book Leadership Without Easy Answers, they introduced adaptive leadership as a way to tackle big problems by helping people wrestle with deeper issues. Heifetz famously said, “Leadership is about disappointing your own people at a rate they can absorb.” It’s about asking challenging questions and allowing room for honest growth.
Skilled leaders build adaptive capacity by demonstrating competency in technical fixes. When an expert knows what to do, these leaders study or engage that expert and implement necessary actions. Building competency within an organization prepares leaders for times when they must navigate uncharted territory. Sometimes, technical fixes and expert opinions are insufficient; leaders must invent new paths, not just new on-ramps. Adaptive capacity enables leaders to address complex challenges through adaptive problem-solving.
Why Adaptive Change Is Essential for Church Leadership Today
Adaptive change has become essential for churches navigating a fast-changing world. Churches are often caught between tradition and the shifting needs of the people they serve. Today’s churches face complex challenges–how to engage younger generations, embrace diversity, and respond to social issues. These challenges can’t be solved with “one-size-fits-all” solutions.
Key leaders in church leadership–like Carey Nieuwhof, Reggie McNeal, Thom Rainer, and Tod Bolsinger–emphasize that adaptive change is essential for the future of the church.
• Tod Bolsinger, author of Canoeing the Mountains: Christian Leadership in Uncharted Territory, compares the church’s journey to the expedition of Lewis and Clark: “You keep looking around, and all you see are mountains. It doesn’t mean you’re lost; it just means you’re somewhere you’ve never been before.” Bolsinger encourages church leaders to adapt and keep moving forward even when they don’t have all the answers.
• Reggie McNeal, a church consultant, calls on churches to shift from an “institutional” mindset to a “mission-focused” one. In Missional Renaissance, he writes, “The most important shifts a church can make are not institutional but missional.” McNeal reminds us that the church’s mission isn’t about maintaining the status quo; it’s about serving and meeting people where they are.
• Carey Nieuwhof, a respected voice in church leadership, believes adaptive change is crucial if churches want to stay relevant, especially for younger generations. He encourages open conversations about burnout, creativity, and renewal, seeing adaptive change as the key to church growth.
• Thom Rainer, CEO of LifeWay Christian Resources, has dedicated much of his work to church health. In his blog Growing Healthy Churches Together, he calls for adaptive leadership to address real-life struggles like declining attendance and inclusivity, urging leaders to create safe, welcoming spaces that meet people’s needs.
The Limits of Technical Change in Today’s Churches
Sometimes, churches turn to technical fixes to solve deeper issues, only to find they don’t quite get where they need to go. Here are two examples that show the limits of technical solutions in church settings:
1. Engagement Through Technology: Many churches have adopted livestreams, social media, and apps to reach more people, especially younger members. While these tools can increase accessibility, they don’t address the core reasons some young people feel disconnected from church life. Adaptive change would mean asking how we can make church life more meaningful and address the real challenges young people face today.
2. Diversity and Inclusion: Some churches have added multilingual services or cultural groups to reflect their communities’ diversity. But if we want true inclusivity, we have to go deeper. Adaptive change calls us to look at our own biases, reshape traditions, and create a place where everyone feels they belong.
How Adaptive Change Can Strengthen Church Communities
Adaptive change encourages churches to look within and ask, How can we be true to our mission, even if it means trying something new? It creates room for resilience, collaboration, and community–a place where people feel they’re seen and valued.
Churches that embrace adaptive change are more likely to develop fresh approaches, reach new people, and stay relevant. When we look at our challenges with honesty and are open to growth, we make room for God to work in ways we may not have expected.
Simple Steps to Start Adaptive Change in Church Leadership
If adaptive change sounds daunting, know that it starts with small steps–just opening a door or starting a conversation. Here are some practical ways to begin:
1. Listen with Openness: Start by truly listening to your congregation, especially those who might feel unheard. Create spaces where people feel free to share their thoughts and needs. This will help you understand what’s really needed.
2. Invite Diverse Perspectives: Make it a priority to include diverse voices. Encourage people from different backgrounds to share their insights. This will open your eyes to new possibilities and bring in fresh ideas.
3. Ask Big Questions: Instead of asking how to “fix” an issue, start with questions like, “What are we missing?” or “How can we serve in a way that truly reflects God’s love?” Adaptive change begins with questions that get to the heart of the matter.
4. Experiment, and Embrace the Journey: Adaptive change means trying new things, even if it’s messy. Each experiment brings us closer to meaningful change.
5. Stay Purpose-Driven: Shift the focus from maintaining programs to embracing the church’s mission. Ask, “How does this help us live out our mission?” When each step is rooted in purpose, the community feels it.
6. Build Relationships that Support Growth: Foster connections within the congregation. Encourage small groups, mentorships, and friendships that empower people to support each other. This creates a resilient, adaptable community.
Embracing the Path of Adaptive Change
Adaptive change is more than a strategy; it’s a journey of faith that church leaders and members take together. It’s the willingness to ask hard questions, to grow in unexpected ways, and to become a church that reflects God’s love and grace in a world that desperately needs it.
There will always be times as you lead when there no known fixes for your problems and that is exactly when you are called to lead with adaptive compacity. Are you ready to start this journey of adaptive change in church leadership? Begin with one step–whether it’s inviting someone into a conversation, taking a risk on a new idea, or opening yourself to listen with fresh ears. As you explore new possibilities, you’ll find others ready to join you in building a church that listens, adapts, and grows in love and purpose. Let’s move forward in faith, trusting that God can work through our questions and lead us into transformation together.
Appendix: Insightful Reading to Learn the Basics of Adaptive Leadership
1. “Adaptive Church: Collaboration and Community in Mission” by Dwight J. Zscheile
This book emphasizes the need for collaboration and innovation within church communities, focusing on how congregations can adapt to cultural changes and engage meaningfully with their surroundings.
2. “Canoeing the Mountains: Christian Leadership in Uncharted Territory” by Tod Bolsinger
Bolsinger applies adaptive leadership concepts to ministry, guiding leaders in navigating unfamiliar challenges in the church, and equipping them to lead in a rapidly changing cultural landscape.
3. “Leading Change” by John P. Kotter
A classic in change management, Kotter’s book outlines an eight-step process for leading organizational change, focusing on the human factors necessary for sustainable transformation.
4. “Leadership on the Line: Staying Alive Through the Dangers of Leading” by Ronald A. Heifetz and Marty Linsky
This foundational book on adaptive leadership highlights the personal and professional risks of leading change and offers strategies for navigating the challenges of difficult leadership roles.
5. “Switch: How to Change Things When Change Is Hard” by Chip Heath and Dan Heath
Combining insights from psychology and organizational change, this book helps leaders understand how to create lasting change by addressing both the rational and emotional elements of change resistance.
6. “Tempered Resilience: How Leaders Are Formed in the Crucible of Change” by Tod Bolsinger
This book explores the development of resilience in leaders facing adaptive challenges, particularly in church contexts, and emphasizes the character formation needed to lead through intense change.
7. “The Other Half of Church: Christian Community, Brain Science, and Overcoming Spiritual Stagnation” by Jim Wilder and Michel Hendricks
Integrating brain science with spiritual growth, this book provides insights into how churches can foster real transformation by understanding the brain’s role in relationships and discipleship.
8. “The Practice of Adaptive Leadership: Tools and Tactics for Changing Your Organization and the World” by Ronald A. Heifetz, Alexander Grashow, and Marty Linsky
Offering practical tools and tactics, this book is a hands-on guide to fostering adaptive change, helping leaders develop the skills necessary to lead effectively in complex environments.
This list serves as an excellent starting point for anyone interested in understanding the fundamentals of adaptive leadership and its application in both organizational and religious contexts.
It is all about seeking Jesus on deeper theological levels.
On TikTok @simplyvinnieblogs
Join my Facebook to find more
spiritual growth resources!
